Purple Teeth - Discover. Drink. Discuss.
Follow me here
  • Purple Teeth Wine Services
    • Wine Tasting
  • Blog
  • Wine & Food
  • Advertise/Sponsor
  • Other stuff

The Battle of Cabernet Sauvignon

31/10/2015

 
Picture
One of the things I love about my job is helping people discover their new favourite wine.  When someone tells me I've opened their mind to a wine, a region, a blend, or a varietal that they'd never considered before, it brings me a lot of joy.  I love it too, when people realise that spending just a couple of pounds more on a bottle can bring infinitely more pleasurable wines.

Exploring what you like to drink now, and what you like to eat, and doing some side-by-side blind tasting is a great way for me to help you figure out the wines that are really going to rock your world. 

Mr Purple Teeth, though, is an open and shut case.  Since the day I met him, he's been Cabernet Sauvignon's number 1 fan.  I've tried many things to make him see that there are other incredible varietals out there.  To be fair to him, he has changed his tastes a lot.  He's even been known to sip the odd Pinot Noir (but, shhhh, don't tell anyone!).  

At heart, he'll always be true and loyal to Cab.  As one of the most famous and highly regarded vinifera, he's not alone.  From top class Bordeaux Blends, to Napa Valley single varietals, and cheap supermarket plonk, Cabernet is a huge hit with red wine fans.  The son of Cabernet Franc and Sauvignon Blanc,  it adds depth, structure and discipline to blends. It's strong blackcurrant notes and age-worthiness mean it's widely planted across the world's wine regions, wherever conditions are right for it to ripen.  (There aren't likely to be English Cab Sauv's for some time, unless global warming comes faster than feared.)

Picture
During the summer, Mr Purple Teeth was lucky enough to visit Canada.  I was not.  My inner green-eyed monster came out even more when he revealed he'd be visiting Kelowna, a food and wine mecca in British Columbia's Okanagan Valley.  He was instructed to bring back wine. Or Else!

We'd enjoyed Okanagan Chardonnays on a trip to Vancouver some years ago, so I expected a white wine, or, perhaps an ice wine.  (He did bring an ice-wine from Syrah and more of that when we get round to tasting it).  I shouldn't have been as surprised as I was when he came back armed with a bottle of Mission Hill Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon (around $24 Canadian dollars at the winery).  I guess I hadn't thought that this grape would do well in Canada.  I was, at the very least, intrigued, if not excited about the prospect.  

Four months after his return, Mr Purple Teeth was ready to taste it, so I agreed to get a nice piece of beef and make Friday night, Cabernet night.  

I had another plan in mind.  Test his taste memory, and get him to open his mind to a different region.   In the spirit of past Chateau Purple Teeth Chardonnay battles, the North versus South Battle of Cabernet Sauvignon was on.

Picture£10.99 at Waitrose till 3/11/15 (14% abv)
The competitor: Journey's End "Sir Lowry" Cabernet Sauvignon 2013, from Stellenbosch, South Africa.  Normally £14.99, it was reduced to £10.99, and there was a 10% further discount for card holders at Waitrose.  It certainly met my requirement: never pay full price for supermarket wine.  And, it put it at a similar price level to the Canadian bottle.  Being the 2013 vintage, it was just 6 months younger than the Mission Hill.  Importantly, though, I'd tried this already at the recent Rugby World Cup Tasting I wrote about recently.  I thought it would meet with Mr Purple Teeth's approval, and overcome his prejudices against South African wine.

We honeymooned in South Africa and enjoyed many wine tastings in Franschhoek and around.  Somehow, in the time since then, his affections for Cape wines had dwindled...  Would this be the one to bring them back to the table? My reputation of knowing what people will like was riding on it...

Picture
I prepared the food: a simple beef joint with horseradish and mustard crust,  mash and broccoli not forgetting the cabernet sauvignon based sauce... I opened both bottles and instantly feared the worse.  The South African cork was much paler.  If one thing instantly turns Mr PT off, it's a wine that is light in colour.  Luckily, in the glass, both wines looked pretty similar, with just a touch deeper purple at the rim in the Canadian glass.  Nothing to worry about.

​And what of the taste?  The Canadian wine had been tasted and approved of, and hand carried back on 2 flights.  Would my choice measure up?

Picture
Both had a ripe blackcurrant core.  Both had hints of stalky green tannin.  Both had some smokey notes and sweet spice.  Both had a good medium body, and similar levels of acidity.  In fact, both were very well balanced examples of a single varietal Cab. The most surprising thing for me was quite how similar they were, given the 10,000 miles that separates their home vineyards...

We tasted them first without food.  

For Mr PT, he felt the South African wine (or wine number 1, to him) was slightly more velvety.  I felt that wine number 2 (from Canada) was a tad riper and fruitier.  It was perhaps a little simpler, but had a more instant appeal.  I rarely choose a single varietal Cabernet Sauvignon. 
The Journey's End is suitable for vegetarians, if that's of concern to you.  Pairing it with beef, as we did, rendered this fact irrelevant.

So how would the wines stand up to the food?

We love enjoying a meal with 2 wines side-by-side and it's great to see how the food changes the flavour of the wine.  In fact, the last time I'd enjoyed a Cabernet was with a steak at Gaucho, where I chose one by Susan Balbo to contrast with a Luigi Bosca Malbec that I'd ordered several times before.  To my surprise, I'll choose the Cabernet next time.

In honesty, the notes got a little shaky towards the end of the meal.  We tried to give attention to the food and wine and enjoy the moment.  If the proof of the pudding is in the eating, then South Africa was a clear winner.  The bottle was empty at the end of the evening, while there was enough of the Canadian Cab left for Mr PT to enjoy a glass another day.  

It's a good result.  The winning Cab Sauv is available locally, while the other requires a transatlantic flight to purchase a bottle.  

I'd love to hear about your favourite single varietal Cabernet Sauvignons, and whether blind tasting wines side by side has changed your opinions and favourites.  Leave a comment here, or on my Facebook page.  

Cheers!


Comments are closed.

    Purple Teeth

    My name's Heather and I've been enjoying wine for over 20 years. I'm the 2013 winner of the Wine and Spirit Education Trust Rhone prize for oustanding students at the advanced level.
    My mission is to share my passion for the myriad varieties of fermented grape juice, hopefully inspiring you to try something new, or to host  a Purple Teeth wine party in your own home or business.

    My blog mainly features wines you should be able to find on your local high street or online, and occasionally, I will review restaurants, travel and other forms of alcohol, since my qualification covers spirits too.  I believe it's important to enjoy the calories and the cash we spend on alcohol, and I hope my guidance can help you reduce the risk of making a bad buy.
      
    When I'm not drinking wine, you'll find me on the dance floor where West Coast Swing is my dance of choice. Socialising with the friends I've made there from all over the world has also brought me new adventures in alcohol!  And just in case you're interested, I also write a blog called Confidence Within.  You'll find it at heatherharrison.weebly.com


    Remember to enjoy wine sensibly...
    For a woman, 2-3 units per day is the recommended maximum allowance.  This equates to around one standard "pub measure" glass of wine:
    175ml of 13% alcohol wine is 2.3 units (and a scary 140 calories).  
    You'll find all the facts you need about safe, moderate drinking at the www.Drinkaware.co.uk site. 
    Purple Teeth supports safe drinking. Never drive or operate machinery after drinking alcohol.

    Get notified of new blogs

    * indicates required
    / ( mm / dd )
    Email Format

    Archives

    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.